04 Jul 2025

Balfour and Macdonald: Clarifying the rules on loss relief

In May 2025 a decision was published by the first-tier tribunal on Charlotte Macdonald v HMRC [2025] regarding income tax relief on a small estate in Derbyshire. This is the most recent in a line of decisions around trade and loss relief for landed estates.

Case overview

Macdonald v HMRC

The Macdonald case concerned a small landed estate in Derbyshire operating a shoot trade and letting of farmland and residential properties. The shoot consistently generated losses between 2017 and 2021 in enough quantity to return net losses for each year in question. HMRC argued the shoot trade was not carried out on a commercial basis. They also argued the activities of the estate were not one business but multiple businesses that shared a location. They claimed the shoot losses were not available for relief.

The first-tier tribunal found the shoot trade was linked to the estate’s operations and was run on a commercial basis. However, not with a reasonable expectation to profit. Sideways loss relief was denied to the taxpayer.

Brander v HMRC

Consideration as to whether the shoot was part of a larger undertaking was referenced to in Brander v HMRC (known as the Balfour case). Although it was an inheritance tax case, Balfour examined whether the business of a Scottish landed estate constituted one trade or multiple trades. The judge found in favour of the taxpayer that the estate was in fact, one business. HMRC appealed to the upper tribunal but were unsuccessful.

Both Macdonald and Brander boil down to an older decision, Scales v Thompson [1927], concerning a business of shipping and underwriting. Scales tried, and failed, to argue that the two areas of the business were one trade. The tribunal ruled that they were separate trades as if the underwriting business ceased, the shipping business would be unaffected and vice versa. Since this, including both Brander and Macdonald, a way of viewing whether there is one business or two has been, would the stopping of one section of the business negatively impact the other parts of the business?

Macdonald found that the shoot did not affect the letting of the farmland on farm business tenancies or grazing licences. If the shoot ceased the farmers wouldn’t be affected by the loss. Similarly, the farming could cease, and the shoot wouldn’t suffer either.

Brander found at the first tier and upper tribunal that the running of the estate, comprised of in hand farming, commercial woodland and letting activities, constituted ‘one business’. There is no distinguishment between business and trade in Brander and they are used interchangeably.

Why the Macdonald case matters?

The Macdonald case potentially sets the scene not just for landed estates, but for all businesses. It highlights situations where one element may be less profitable but remains essential to the overall operation.

Additionally, whether there is one business or two can significantly impact business property relief. If activities are treated as separate, non-qualifying elements may trigger unexpected inheritance tax liabilities.

Its seems that landowners and other businesses are facing increased tax costs with restrictions on loss reliefs and the proposed changes to inheritance tax relief announced in the Budget 2024.

The above is a very thumbnail summary of a complex and subjective area. We’re here to help if you’re concerned about loss relief or business property relief for your business or landed estate.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
GDPR permissions

Latest news

PenCarrie acquires premium outdoor clothing specialist

19 November 2026

Read
Three colleagues engaged in discussion around a laptop

PKF Francis Clark records 99% client satisfaction in latest survey

17 November 2026

Read
The brick exterior of The Brewhouse Theatre & Arts Centre on a sunny day, featuring performance posters near the entrance.

Liquidators appointed to Taunton Theatre Association

16 November 2026

Read
A couple listens to an advisor while discussing business succession planning.

Understanding inheritance tax when making charitable gifts in your will

13 November 2026

Read
A group of professional employee sitting around a conference table, engaged in discussion, symbolizing collaboration and workplace benefits.

R&D claim notification form requirement to end in April 2027 

11 November 2026

Read
Two male colleagues sat at a laptop, deep in conversation.

Foreign permanent establishment exemption: what changes?

10 November 2026

Read
Two people stare at a computer screen with a message to say their cyber security has been breached.

Cyber security for charities: five questions trustees should ask

9 November 2026

Read

HMRC’s September update on payrolling benefits in kind changes

6 November 2026

Read
Image of Man stood in office windows looking out to a composition of other office buildings.

International expansion: balancing growth opportunities with tax risk

6 November 2026

Read
An elevated scenic view of St Ives Harbour and beach in Cornwall, showing a sandy bay, turquoise water, coastal buildings, and flowers in the foreground.

England’s Overnight Visitor Levy

3 November 2026

Read
A diverse group of business professionals standing in a bright office corridor, listening to a woman holding a digital tablet.

How to build a 12-month finance transformation roadmap as a new finance director

2 November 2026

Read
A large group of workers in yellow high-visibility jackets and beanies stand in an outdoor field behind a banner. The banner features the QMS logo, a comic book superhero character, and the text "Passionate People Delivering Excellence On Time, Every Time! QMS.UK".

QMS: Building a successful business with trusted advisers by its side

2 November 2026

Read